While this was an interesting thought experiment, I am coming around to the idea that it is not likely to lead to a terribly fun game; and as we can see from the date of the last post I have not been putting cycles into it.
I will probably move my FPW gaming to a smaller scale of game using Hearts of Tin as an engine; when and if I do I will post a link to this blog.
Thanks to those who have followed. If you want to pick up any ideas that are here and run with them, feel free.
OK on second thought look at this as a guilt-free hiatus.
OK, on third thought I'm back looking at FPW.
Notes as I work on a design for a Franco-Prussian War miniatures game. And these are notes and musings, not conclusions. Comments, corrections and observations are *more* than welcome.
15 February 2012
22 November 2011
Lets try to get this moving again.
I have been over-focusing on WWII for a while; time to return to a period that at least had prettier uniforms.
A couple thoughts to implement first:
A couple thoughts to implement first:
- 40mm square bases- near as matters 1.5" - should look at bit nicer for the brigades, plus I could use them at need for half-scale Volley and Bayonet. I'll re-base the Germans this weekend.
- The "hidden information under base" method makes blinds redundant.
- While Gravellotte/St. Privat can be a straight-up fight, Mars-la-Tour depends totally on neither side knowing the enemy situation. Which means you need to have available the whole potential OB for both sides, and some mechanism for secretly working out which is true and getting everything in place. The V&B Road to Glory system, which uses a card draw to conceal or re-schedule some assets, adjusting victory based on the draw, is a good start point. But sorting and organizing takes some of the precious play time, so carefully!
29 October 2011
Blinds, Dummies, and secret information
I draw your attention to this post on my general blog. I think the idea will work for this game as well. FPW is not off the books, I am just going where the interest leads me.
07 August 2011
The Pits and the Pendulum
I have been thinking through the "1 stand = 1 Brigade idea.
- On the pro side, it will cut the required time down compared to, say, stand = regiment
- Con: Small number of units may lead to "everything up front"
02 August 2011
01 August 2011
Blinds, time and uncertainty
We have to have uncertainty. This has special importance for Mars-la-Tour, where the key to the battle was Bazaine's uncertainty as to the Prussian forces blocking him, and the Prussian uncertainty as to the actual location of the French army.
I have written earlier of the use of blinds, which I still quite like in general The problem they present for us are twofold. First, they add time; second they take figures off the table making for both a less attractive table and an issue of storage on side table.
The minimalist way to deal with this is to place figures on the table for all possible units. For convenience, reveals will be by entire corps. Unrevealed units can be kept in a compact and easy-to-maneuver mass. A simple set of reveal rules can then be used to require (or allow) a unit to deploy into its true, revealed formation. Once revealed, it will be far simpler if the unit then stays revealed for the balance of the game.
These rules will only be interesting, I suspect, only when there are at least two Corps on a side. Looking at the war in general, that means are looking at rules for 3 historical battles:
While one should be able to play the exact historical OBs, I think for replay value it will also be desirable to have some sort of randomization mechanism to alter the OBs so total enemy forces faced are as uncertain as their locations.
I have written earlier of the use of blinds, which I still quite like in general The problem they present for us are twofold. First, they add time; second they take figures off the table making for both a less attractive table and an issue of storage on side table.
The minimalist way to deal with this is to place figures on the table for all possible units. For convenience, reveals will be by entire corps. Unrevealed units can be kept in a compact and easy-to-maneuver mass. A simple set of reveal rules can then be used to require (or allow) a unit to deploy into its true, revealed formation. Once revealed, it will be far simpler if the unit then stays revealed for the balance of the game.
These rules will only be interesting, I suspect, only when there are at least two Corps on a side. Looking at the war in general, that means are looking at rules for 3 historical battles:
- Mars-la-Tour
- Gravelotte-St. Privat
- Sedan
- Mas-la-Tour through Gravelotte-St. Privat as a three day campaign.
While one should be able to play the exact historical OBs, I think for replay value it will also be desirable to have some sort of randomization mechanism to alter the OBs so total enemy forces faced are as uncertain as their locations.
Well, that's not going to work
Let me walk through a little calculation I just did
Six seconds!! I've managed games with that many stands where I could do that, but only where the stand is a unit of number and the real decision applies to a multi-stand unit - at around 20-30 seconds for each unit for each phase I think we actually have enough time. And I am a fast player.
How can we mitigate all this. Well, we can go to simultaneous movement. If we get things clean enough I think it can be managed while keeping up the stream of decisions. But this is a minor point; simultaneous turns can be more complex that Igo-yougo.
Another (simpler) approach is to cut the stand count and simplify the usage. This may need a scale change as well, but lets think about it.
So, here's an alternative. We have cut the number of stands per division in two, and deleted or pushed to army the attached and logistics. With a division at two stands, it really has three or four formations -- meaning the decision points are significantly reduced. I have also generated two types of artillery stand - one with one gun and one with two. Lets see how it looks:
One thing I like here is the ratio of half infantry and half support. We still have some issues of division frontage and ground scale. I'll look a that next.
| 3 | hours in the game | |||
| 180 | minutes in the game | |||
| 6 | turns (2 hours/turn) | |||
| 30 | which works out to minutes/turn | |||
| 1800 | which is second/turn | |||
| 100 | stands for each player | |||
| 18 | so we have seconds/stand each turn | |||
| 3 | phases/turn as an assumption (we will think about how that allocates out) | |||
| 6 | giving seconds/stand-phase |
Six seconds!! I've managed games with that many stands where I could do that, but only where the stand is a unit of number and the real decision applies to a multi-stand unit - at around 20-30 seconds for each unit for each phase I think we actually have enough time. And I am a fast player.
How can we mitigate all this. Well, we can go to simultaneous movement. If we get things clean enough I think it can be managed while keeping up the stream of decisions. But this is a minor point; simultaneous turns can be more complex that Igo-yougo.
Another (simpler) approach is to cut the stand count and simplify the usage. This may need a scale change as well, but lets think about it.
So, here's an alternative. We have cut the number of stands per division in two, and deleted or pushed to army the attached and logistics. With a division at two stands, it really has three or four formations -- meaning the decision points are significantly reduced. I have also generated two types of artillery stand - one with one gun and one with two. Lets see how it looks:
| French | Stands | Figures | Type | Basing | |
| Corps Command | 1 | 1 | Mounted command | 30mm round | |
| Infantry | 6 | 36 | Line Infantry | 40x30 | |
| 6 | Light Infantry | 2 on one above per div | |||
| 3 | Foot command | on one above per div | |||
| Cavalry | 1 | 6 | Hussar and Lancers | 40x30 | |
| Heavy Artillery | 1 | 1 | Guns (with crew) | 30x30 | |
| Light Artillery | 1 | 2 | Guns (with crew) | 40x30 | |
| Horse Artillery | 1 | 1 | Guns (with crew) | 30x30 | |
| Mitrailleus | 1 | 1 | MG all up | 30x30 | |
| Total | 12 | ||||
| German | Stands | Figures | Type | Basing | |
| Corps Command | 1 | 1 | Mounted command | 30mm round | |
| Infantry | 4 | 32 | Line Infantry | 40x30 | |
| 2 | Foot command | on one above per div | |||
| Heavy Artillery | 1 | 2 | Guns (with crew) | 40x30 | |
| Light Artillery | 1 | 2 | Guns (with crew) | 40x30 | |
| Horse Artillery | 1 | 1 | Guns (with crew) | 30x30 | |
| Total | 8 |
One thing I like here is the ratio of half infantry and half support. We still have some issues of division frontage and ground scale. I'll look a that next.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)